Is Harry Gay

[HeadHunter]

I am not saying so but this person is

Controversial US critic claims Harry is gay

Controversial US critic Michael Bronski has made claims that Harry Potter might be gay, by claiming that JK Rowling's phenomenally successful books mirror the experiences of young gay people. He said: "It struck me in the first few pages that there was a revolt against accepted conventional life. A lot of gay people I know read the books that way and it really mirrors their own experiences."

"It is astonishing the interpretation people can put on something," said a source close to the author. "There is nothing in these claims

[Stands Alone]

I really think he is. Seriously. He is not hitting on Hermionie, nor, he acknowledged the fact in the fourth book she was a girl. I really think he is. :funny: :funny:

[HeadHunter]

Originally posted by Stands Alone
I really think he is. Seriously. He is not hitting on Hermionie, nor, he acknowledged the fact in the fourth book she was a girl. I really think he is. :funny: :funny:

http://www.handykult.de/plaudersmilies.de/happy/mdrmed.gif HAHA good point but NO http://www.handykult.de/plaudersmilies.de/angryfire.gif

[ChildofDarkness]

:funny: That's great. But seriously now I don't think he is. You must remember his crush on Cho Chang, who is a girl.

[HeadHunter]

Originally posted by ChildofDarkness
:funny: That's great. But seriously now I don't think he is. You must remember his crush on Cho Chang, who is a girl.

yeah i know...seriously i really think half these critics really dont read the books

[pickledonions]

HARRY POTTER IS NOT GAY... Tom Riddle is !!!!!!

[HeadHunter]

Originally posted by pickledonions
HARRY POTTER IS NOT GAY... Tom Riddle is !!!!!!

hehe

[pickledonions]

Tome Riddle is as bent as the day is long. He where's pink pants.

[HeadHunter]

Originally posted by pickledonions
Tome Riddle is as bent as the day is long. He where's pink pants.

he does???....*Tries to look shocked* :D

[pickledonions]

Yeah..You see them in CoS..When he's running with Harry saying "Chase me...Chase me... hee hee .... your it!" slapping harry with his wand.

HAHAAHAA.

*Pickledonions rolls around his jar, with joy*

[HeadHunter]

Originally posted by pickledonions
Yeah..You see them in CoS..When he's running with Harry saying "Chase me...Chase me... hee hee .... your it!" slapping harry with his wand.

HAHAAHAA.

*Pickledonions rolls around his jar, with joy*


ooooooooooookay http://www.handykult.de/plaudersmilies.de/eek4.gif what you bin smokin http://www.handykult.de/plaudersmilies.de/smokin.gif

[pickledonions]

nothin...i'm just in a good mood.

(plus Tom Riddle IS gay)

:)

[HeadHunter]

soooo why you in a good modd *in an inquizative tone of voice*

[pickledonions]

Originally posted by HeadHunter
soooo why you in a good modd *in an inquizative tone of voice*

I'm getting to the end of my shift at work (12hrs in office)...My bed is calling me. :sleepy:

Thinking of reading OotP for a 2nd time tonight aswell.

[HeadHunter]

Originally posted by pickledonions
I'm getting to the end of my shift at work (12hrs in office)...My bed is calling me. :sleepy:

Thinking of reading OotP for a 2nd time tonight aswell.

you are at work :eek: *realises that the world does not run at Uk time*...oh okay...what time is it there

[pickledonions]

no no no. I'm from UK too.
I've been at work since 11am.

I work for an online bank...

[HeadHunter]

Originally posted by pickledonions
no no no. I'm from UK too.
I've been at work since 11am.

I work for an online bank...

well good god thats along day

well night then

[ChildofDarkness]

Tom Riddle gay? But he is Voldemort so Voldemort would be gay. Next someone will be saying that he is trying to kill Harry because he turned down an invitation to go on a date.

[HeadHunter]

Originally posted by ChildofDarkness
Tom Riddle gay? But he is Voldemort so Voldemort would be gay. Next someone will be saying that he is trying to kill Harry because he turned down an invitation to go on a date.

maybe Dd was lying

[que_SuertE777]

Originally posted by HeadHunter
Controversial US critic Michael Bronski has made claims that Harry Potter might be gay, by claiming that JK Rowling's phenomenally successful books mirror the experiences of young gay people. He said: "It struck me in the first few pages that there was a revolt against accepted conventional life. A lot of gay people I know read the books that way and it really mirrors their own experiences."


OK, so Harry Potter's life mirrors their own experiences. So I'm guessing their parents were killed by an all-powerful evil wizard and they fly around on broomsticks, levetate objects, know people who can turn into animals, have seen dragons and hippogryffs and all sorts of magical creatures, and know of a whole different world filled with magic, witches, wizards, and the like. Yes, I'm sure that that really mirrors the experiences of gay people.

[moviegeek]

sure, voldemort doesn't want to kill him, he just wants him to be his lover.

[que_SuertE777]

Hey, love and hate go together sometimes.

[pickledonions]

Originally posted by moviegeek
sure, voldemort doesn't want to kill him, he just wants him to be his lover.

Thats what i thought...

Maybe Voldy turned up at Harry house when he was a baby, asking James and Lilly, for Harry's hand in marriage. They said " NO. NO .NO." He said " Die ".

Could of happened...;)

[HeadHunter]

mmmmmmaybe....
..
...
....
.....
......Oh maybe the guys just a nut ball

[pickledonions]

Originally posted by HeadHunter
mmmmmmaybe....
..
...
....
.....
......Oh maybe the guys just a nut ball

:shock: Who me or Voldy? hmmm.

[Laterose]

the guy who came up with this crap

[pickledonions]

Originally posted by Laterose
the guy who came up with this crap

That'll be then.... cheers. I'm leaving now and not coming back. Bye all.

[moviegeek]

bye

[Laterose]

see yah

[pickledonions]

NASTY PEOPLE... making me feel welcome?!

[HeadHunter]

Originally posted by pickledonions
:shock: Who me or Voldy? hmmm.

the guy that i started this thread about http://www.handykult.de/plaudersmilies.de/rolleyes.gif

[pickledonions]

Thanks HeadHunter... I think i'll stick around.. (HEE HE!)

[HeadHunter]

yup STAY

[pickledonions]

Ok i will, thank you...

Anyway, the thread...

I just cant see any things in the books that makes me think that he gay. Nothing. He likes girls, he plays full-contact sports, he loves fatty foods, etc. Its a silly idea.

[DeereX]

This is so stupid. It's like the news that the t-rex in JP3 was a homosexual.

[Havok]

Good advice from your Grandad , Pickle

Harry is gay , a three headed hell hound told me

[pickledonions]

The HeLL Hound lied!! He just isn't gay.

[HeadHunter]

Originally posted by Havok
Good advice from your Grandad , Pickle

Harry is gay , a three headed hell hound told me

thats just becasue Harry told them to go shove there Heads up there arse

[ChildofDarkness]

Havok, you speak dog?

And I think que has an extremely good point on this. What part of the Harry Potter series do they relate with?

[Laterose]

the part about living

[Iben]

Harry's dad seemed to be a bit of a player at Harry's age, but Harry has yet to show any sign of anything like that, he didn't seem very eager to hold hands with Cho or make out on their date...so maybe...nah

[HeadHunter]

what year was that scene in Oop from with snapes memery...maybe Harry will get hornyer in the next two :)

[WebMonkey]

Hopefully he will...but not in a cheesey way. He is famous in the wizard world, girls must want to be next to him but he must learn how to handle it. I think that he'll have twice as many girls after him next term... Hermy will have to help him beat them off.

[HeadHunter]

i expected to have loads of girls wanting him from the first book....

[pickledonions]

I think monkey is right. WebMonkey is our King !!

[HeadHunter]

Originally posted by pickledonions
I think monkey is right. WebMonkey is our King !!

http://www.handykult.de/plaudersmilies.de/eek3.gif

[WebMonkey]

How do you do all those faces?There cool..

Harry will become a stud.. King stud. But do you think that he'll be like his dad when it comes to chasing the girls. The more i think about this matter, the more i think the likelyhood of a love triangle starting between Harry, Ron and Hermione. This could be a very large sub-plot of the 7th book?

What you guys think?

[que_SuertE777]

Originally posted by HeadHunter
what year was that scene in Oop from with snapes memery...maybe Harry will get hornyer in the next two :)

It was their fifth year because all of them were taking their O.W.L.s. Remember? Lupin was studying for his.

[Havok]

Well an I heard Harry dies of wizard warts in the 7th novel ?? The only way he could have gotten those is by having gay $ex.

bark bark

[que_SuertE777]

o...k...

[WebMonkey]

Originally posted by Havok
Well an I heard Harry dies of wizard warts in the 7th novel ?? The only way he could have gotten those is by having gay $ex.

bark bark :lol:

[HeadHunter]

Originally posted by que_SuertE777
It was their fifth year because all of them were taking their O.W.L.s. Remember? Lupin was studying for his.

okay so harry isnt not like his father much then...maybe because he didnt grow up with his father being around....but if you think about it is that James wanted Lily and Harry wants Cho....i rest my case http://www.handykult.de/plaudersmilies.de/smokin.gif

[que_SuertE777]

Yes, but Harry doesn't show off or have a big ego like James did. Wait... what was your case?

[HeadHunter]

i dont know i got confused half through writing it and gave up http://www.handykult.de/plaudersmilies.de/faga1.gif

[que_SuertE777]

:D :rolleyes: heh

[Kerry from Cali]

Originally posted by pickledonions
Yeah..You see them in CoS..When he's running with Harry saying "Chase me...Chase me... hee hee .... your it!" slapping harry with his wand.

HAHAAHAA.




(snort) LOL
"slapping Harry with his wand..."

That could be taken in *so* the wrong way. ;) :shock: :funny: :p


kerry =)

[pickledonions]

Originally posted by Kerry from Cali
(snort) LOL
"slapping Harry with his wand..."

That could be taken in *so* the wrong way. ;) :shock: :funny: :p


kerry =)

He Hee :D
I know, and it should! ;) :lol:

[bludemun]

Originally posted by WebMonkey
Hopefully he will...but not in a cheesey way. He is famous in the wizard world, girls must want to be next to him but he must learn how to handle it. I think that he'll have twice as many girls after him next term... Hermy will have to help him beat them off.

Good thing you put the word "them" in your last sentence, otherwise it takes a whole different meaning!

"You must flick your wand just so..."

[WebMonkey]

HA HA HA! Good one Bludemun... (maybe i mis-spelt it!!!)

[HeadHunter]

Originally posted by bludemun
Good thing you put the word "them" in your last sentence, otherwise it takes a whole different meaning!

"You must flick your wand just so..."

he put them in the sentance...where

[Laterose]

Originally posted by Kerry from Cali
(snort) LOL
"slapping Harry with his wand..."

That could be taken in *so* the wrong way. ;) :shock: :funny: :p


kerry =)
;)

[HeadHunter]

Originally posted by Kerry from Cali
(snort) LOL
"slapping Harry with his wand..."

That could be taken in *so* the wrong way. ;) :shock: :funny: :p


kerry =)

http://www.handykult.de/plaudersmilies.de/tales/merlin.gif

[WebMonkey]

How do you do all those Emoticons?

[Stands Alone]

http://www.esmileys.com/mig/albums./msnsmileys/by-Eric%20Trudeau-aim%20smileys-Jam_%27n%20face.gif

Like that?

[HeadHunter]

Originally posted by WebMonkey
How do you do all those Emoticons?

everyone wants to be like The Hunter http://www.handykult.de/plaudersmilies.de/outtahere.gif

[que_SuertE777]

Lol, it looks like you're the hunted ;)

[LOTRfan]

Originally posted by que_SuertE777
Yes, but Harry doesn't show off or have a big ego like James did.

Yea, it's funny because Harry is the only one of the two that actually deserves to show off. What did James ever do in school? Get popular? HA!
I don't think J.k.'s ever going to make it "easy" for Harry. She wants him to have troubles so her readers can relate to him. It would have been too perfect for everyone to flock after Harry and all the girls to love him- as they rightly should;) Although we'd like to see him become really popular (like the D.A. thing), the common public would be disappointed with a hero like that. I think they'd rather see a skinny, messy-haired kid who was bullied most of his life end up saving the wizarding world. It wouldn't be in his character to ever enjoy popularity even if it does eventually befall him. The thing is- Harry should be insanely popular because of the kind of person he is and all the things he's done. Yet he isn't. It lets readers know its OK not to be the coolest person in school or be well liked by everyone as long as you know you are being the best person you can be. And as long as you are doing what you believe in and what you feel is right. As for those ppl that refuse to believe Voldy is back? Heck with em!

[que_SuertE777]

Originally posted by LOTRfan
As for those ppl that refuse to believe Voldy is back? Heck with em!

:applaud: I'm with ya on this one LOTRfan. Lol, James has an ego that would rival some football players' that I know.

[Stands Alone]

I found him to be one great "broomstick up the butt" character. I couldn't believe he was all like that, I really thought he would be a nice character. But, no.

[WebMonkey]

http://www.handykult.de/plaudersmilies.de/scatter.gif

(i know how it do them now Headhunter, Ta)

[hpk37067]

Hey, I want to know how!

[que_SuertE777]

Go to a site with emoticons and copy the address of them and paste them to your reply.

[hpk37067]

Gotcha! Thank you.

[que_SuertE777]

Welcome

[Tim37ninjageniu]

Who wants to bet on how long this thread is goin to stay open? Any bidders?

[WebMonkey]

48hours......

oh..and Harry's not gay.

[hpk37067]

Why are we wondering whether Harry is gay or not? People, this book is for young people. I don't think Harry will tunr out ot be gay.

[que_SuertE777]

I think we've all agreed that he's definitely straight.

[hpk37067]

Yep.

[WebMonkey]

I Concur.

[hpk37067]

:mad: You concur a lot don't ya?

[funnie bunnie]

Okay, one question.......who thought Harry was gay in the first place???

[Stands Alone]

I was the first one to respond in this thread thinking Harry was gay. So, take your anger out on me, cause I was the person. But, I have different thoughts on it now. And after re reading the 5th book, I see a "no he is not gay sign".

[funnie bunnie]

Originally posted by Stands Alone
I was the first one to respond in this thread thinking Harry was gay. So, take your anger out on me, cause I was the person. But, I have different thoughts on it now. And after re reading the 5th book, I see a "no he is not gay sign".


Don't worry....it's not like I was gonna jump on you and claw your eyes out.....hehe

I was just kinda looking for reasons why people would find him queer.....;)

[Stands Alone]

Well, you may never know. I mean. there is nothing wrong with anyone being gay....they are like everyone else. If Harry ended up being gay (Not saying that he would be, JK's decision) it wouldn't really change the book in my opinion.


Thank god you wouldn't do that....heh.

[que_SuertE777]

Actually, funnie bunnie, no one here thought he was gay. HeadHunter just found an article or w/e saying this ingnorant critic thought he was.
Originally posted by HeadHunter
Controversial US critic Michael Bronski has made claims that Harry Potter might be gay, by claiming that JK Rowling's phenomenally successful books mirror the experiences of young gay people. He said: "It struck me in the first few pages that there was a revolt against accepted conventional life. A lot of gay people I know read the books that way and it really mirrors their own experiences."

[WebMonkey]

Originally posted by hpk37067
:mad: You concur a lot don't ya?

I con... sorry. Yes i say that alot. Its just a nice way of saying " yes, your correct." without licking your a**e !! :)

[flunky]

I don't think he's gay, I mean, come on! Where in the book say that he is? Or what signs do the book have?

[que_SuertE777]

There aren't any signs. Only the imaginary ones that the stupid critic has created in his small little mind. And even those aren't the least substantial.

[Evy]

Originally posted by flunky
I don't think he's gay, I mean, come on! Where in the book say that he is? Or what signs do the book have?

I agree there are NO signs in the book that would direct a reader to thinking Harry is gay. It's another one of those ppl who had nothing better to do than write an article about a bunch of bull