the Village vs the Forgotten

[Tyranic_Lord]

Both received mixed reviews and werent as highly praised as the Sixth Sense but did outstandingly well in the box office. So which turned out better for you?

[neo5595]

The Forgotten was a terrible moive. I really liked the Village though. It had an outstanding score, great acting, great costume design, and great cinematography.

[Halofan1]

Neither.

[Dilophosaurus89]

Oh please, spare me The forgotten, The Village had more talent in its set design than the forgotten had in the entire film.

[Crow T. Robot]

Both films were mediocre. The only thing the viewer should be suprised about at the end of The Village was that it wasnt a thriller.

[Drizzt240]

Haven't seen either but the Forgotten looks like pure crap. I know a lot of people didn't like the Village, but I loved it.

[New_Breed]

liked both but the village had one hell of a score wich puts it above forgotten.

[vision_afar]

I didn't like The Forgotten at all. It was a good idea and could have been a good film.

[project Doom]

I loved The Village, and although The Forgotten was ok, it could have been better.

[iv3rdawG]

Haven't seen either but the Forgotten looks like pure crap. I know a lot of people didn't like the Village, but I loved it.
I thought you said you didnt see either?

[Nimrandir]

Neither were good. The village was an intelligent movie until it was destroyed by the stupid way in which the plot twists were revealed and used. The FOrgotten was not anything special.

[Drizzt240]

I thought you said you didnt see either?
:funny:

I don't know why I put that, I just meant to say I haven't seen the Forgotten.

[PapaRoachRules]

i haven't seen forgotten yet, but the village was great, so thats my vote

[FilmJerk]

I wish I could of Forgotten all about The Village

[magicmedicine]

I wish I could of Forgotten all about The Village

same, so ill go with the forgotten even thou i havnt seen it :P

[Fanible]

Is this serious? The Forgotten, was... blah. It was interesting for about half the movie, then it became ultra cheesy and had a really bad ending. The Village is my vote, by a long shot.

[Gomamon]

I haven´t seen any of them, so I voted for The Forgotten after seeing the trailer.

[youthinasia]

Tough call. I'd probably say The Village, but only by a close margin.

[Boods]

both were extremely disappointing imo
but the village had joaquim phoenix who is an incredible actor so i vote the village

[Crow T. Robot]

both were extremely disappointing imo
but the village had joaquim phoenix who is an incredible actor so i vote the village


He had about 5 lines in the film.....

[Nimrandir]

It was a little disapointing about his lines, but Bryce Dalas Howard was an excellant actress.

[stonefaced_1]

Neither. Even though I love below average thrillers.;)

[objectionalmen]

so which one should i rent

[Glordreen]

Both suck. But The Village at least was better in the first half.

[Brock Landers]

I haven't seen "The Forgotten" yet.....but just for clarification "The Village" sucked.

[MonsterManiac]

The ending of the Forgotten was lame.If it had a better ending,I would of loved this movie.The Village was better.

[fantasticfour40]

I enjoyed the Forgotten better.

[Darth Barth]

I liked both ok enough, but the village was a little better.

The best part about the Forgotton was when that dude got sucked right out of the house, made me jump, I was not expecting it then.

[Nimrandir]

The Village was an insult to me as a viewer.