What if Jackman and Jane swapped roles?

[stunt double]

How would it looked like had Thomas Jane played Logan/Wolverine and Hugh Jackman played Castle/Punisher?

Can you picture that? I watched the new Punisher and there's shades of Wolverine. And Jackman's Wolvie had Punisher tones in his ferocity.

[poeman]

:nono:

[stunt double]

I take that as a no...

[Switzer]

No I can't see that happening.I had my first impression of the Punisher so now I can't change it.

[mentiroso]

They look similar, act similar. You could swap them and no one would notice.

[Doomsday]

I think Jackman would have made a hell of a Punisher, but he's already completely typecast as Wolverine.

[Tony Montana]

no

[anaria22]

I could almost see that as working. Though I think whatever role Jackman was in would be played better.

[Kable24]

It would be cool to see a Wolverine/Punisher movie. "a fanboys wet dream"

[Rocketboy]

Nope.
Each man defines their character.
Perfect casting in both cases, IMO.

[Rocketboy]

Originally posted by Kable24
It would be cool to see a Wolverine/Punisher movie. "a fanboys wet dream" I'd rather see Punisher with Daredevil or Spidey (or all 3). They were always great stories in the comics.
Or even better all 4, like the "Confederacy of Dunces" story arc in the Punisher (and throw in the Hulk for good measure).
But none of these would ever happen.

[bbf2]

Originally posted by stunt double
How would it looked like had Thomas Jane played Logan/Wolverine and Hugh Jackman played Castle/Punisher?

Can you picture that? I watched the new Punisher and there's shades of Wolverine. And Jackman's Wolvie had Punisher tones in his ferocity.

Hypothetical questions don't solve anything son.

If you were stuck in an elevator with the Pope, Ralph Nader, and your mom, who would you smack on the head with your shoe?

[NitWit]

Seriously, I dont' think Jane could grow the facial hair to play wolverine.

And i'd hit my mom first, then ralph nader, then nader again, back to my mom and finally the pope

[Frizzo the Clown]

Originally posted by bbf2
Hypothetical questions don't solve anything son.

If you were stuck in an elevator with the Pope, Ralph Nader, and your mom, who would you smack on the head with your shoe? Thats easy. My Mom.

[Benz]

Hugh Jackman is alot more talented than Thomas Jane in my opinion.