Rate The Battle of Helm's Deep

[Smeagol]

How was it for you?

[PsYkOoOoO]

nth beats it....yet

[loyis7]

Originally posted by PsYkOoOoO
nth beats it....yet

Untill The Return Of The King comes out of course. ;)

[PsYkOoOoO]

yea...thats why i typed 'yet'

[loyis7]

Who voted for the 4th option ???

[PsYkOoOoO]

i dont want to know..coz the last time i asked i got jumped on.hahaa

[Smeagol]

Originally posted by loyis7
Who voted for the 4th option ???

There's always one! :rolleyes:

[Slipknot]

Nothing beats the ballte yet.... but Pellanor Fields VERY MUCH better beat it.

[Marvin Nash]

Burley Brawl was better!


I'm gonna get shot... ;)

[Seraph333]

It was good.

[scifi guy]

Helms Deep will be the best battle ever until ROTK comes out!:applaud:

[Mat]

What were those elves doing there anyway? ;)

It was a great battle; one of the greatest of all time.

[Gandollum]

It was a pretty good battle but i felt it had some problems with it.
I was hoping for the battle to be a bit more bloodier and more scenes that had close up batte shots. I also wanted it to be longer and without any interuptions[Waiting for EE]. But in terms of best battle sequences, Helms Deep has the best pg-13 battle while Braveheart and Saving Private Ryan have the best and most realistic battles.

[downflow311]

i liked it, but it will soon be obsolete. i fear the TTT will be ultimately forgettable because ROTK will be so much more massive.

[Balrog of Moria]

It was spectacular

[Madskillz]

It was great but would luv more from the book.. that was awesome..

[The Moose]

amazing, and the best battle out there. until ROTK

[Queen Arwen]

I chose to vote for the second option because I feel I can be justified when I say that BOTPF will blow it out of the water! :D

[DolAmroth]

I think like in a year they should get all the EE dvd's for all 3 films and put them all together in a huge set and add like 3 more hours of new footage for maximum detail and make it rated R and have complete realistic battles.

[todd philip]

I AGREE DOL

[cg124]

That would be cool

[todd philip]

i voted for the second option, cause it feels a tad pg-13y to me!

[The Moose]

PJ has said that they are not going to put them all together (the EEs)

[Dogbert0228]

It doesn't matter what PJ says, it matters what New Line does. And I'm willing to bet that New Line will release a box set. Not too soon after ROTK, but maybe in several years... Perhaps 5-10 year anniversary, if not sooner, then for the 20th or 25th anniversary, they'll go in and a la Star Wars, remaster the soundtrack and computer annimation to keep it up to speed with the times... Probably a theatrical re-release, and then all new DVDs (or whatever movies are released on in 25 years... HD-DVDs, who knows... :))

[The Moose]

that would be cool, seeing it with even better CGI in 20 something years

[PsYkOoOoO]

how do u perfect on perfection?

[DolAmroth]

I dont think you could really make the battles look more realistic I mean they could be more bloody and gory but the huge epic shots of the thousands of Urak Hai marching how could that look more real.

[PsYkOoOoO]

well maybe gollum...you never know...no matter how great a CGI is these days...it still looks fake...

[DolAmroth]

Yeah but I mean gollum does look pretty freaken real but I guess he could look even more realistic. but the battle seens look ar real as real

[The Moose]

but in the future, the computers will be more poweful, so they could put in a heap ore detail, such as individual scratches, and stuff like that

[PsYkOoOoO]

but we wont be able to see it right?too small

[The Moose]

not in ROTK that we are getting in December. who knows about the future?